what did frederick engels say about the history of force <


Frederick Engels argued that force is not an independent, primary factor in history, but rather a tool dependent on economic conditions for ultimate success in War. While acknowledging force as the "midwife" of new societies and a revolutionary instrument, he maintained that economic power (production, technology, and resources) determines the success of political force, not vice versa. w michaelharrison.or Key aspects of Engels' views on the history of force <



Key aspects of Engels' views on the history of force include: • Subordination to Economics: Engels argued against the idea that force creates economic situations. Instead, he maintained that force can only be created and sustained by economic means, specifically the ability to fund and arm a military force.<


W michaelharrison.or... +1 • The "Midwife" of History: In Anti-Dühring, Engels acknowledged the revolutionary role of force, stating that in history, it is the "midwife of every old society which is pregnant with a new one". @ www.marxists.org


• Refutation of Dühring: Engels heavily criticized Eugen Dühring's view that forced robbery is the primary historical factor. Engels argued that for robbery to work, there must be a developed production system to steal from, placing the economic act before the violent act. I


michaelharrison.or... +1Industrialization and Force: In his work The Role of Force in History, Engels emphasized that modern military power relies on industrial capability-such as metallurgy and coal-meaning economic development defines military superiority. © www.marxists.org <



• Role in German History: Engels analyzed Bismarck's policy of "blood and iron" ", showing how it temporarily allowed the landed aristocracy to dominate, but was still ultimately dependent on the economic rise of the German bourgeoisie. g www.goodreads.com +1 <



Engels concluded that while force can cause significant destruction and alter political trajectories, it is ultimately subjected to the superior force of economic development. •... Ask anything Q what did frederick engels say about the history of <




https://www.google.com/search?q=what+did+frederick+engels+say+about+the+history+of+force&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&hl=en-us&client=safari#lfId=ChxjMe